Repairs vs. Improvements: Knowing the Difference

Tax Accountant is a network of experienced professionals and proactive accountants. We offer a wide range of accounting and tax services; Contact us today to discuss your requirements

Ya Allah keep me safe and increase my susbsitance

Get Professional Help for Your Business

As a landlord, it’s crucial to understand the distinction between repairs and improvements for rental properties when it comes to tax implications. Knowing the difference can help you maximise deductions and avoid unexpected tax bills. In this guide, we’ll delve into the nuances of distinguishing between repairs and improvements, discussing common areas of ambiguity and outlining the tax implications. By the end, you’ll be better prepared to make informed decisions about property maintenance and ensure that you’re taking advantage of the appropriate tax relief. Let’s get started!

When it comes to property maintenance, repairs are essential for keeping everything in good shape. This includes fixing broken items, replacing worn-out components, and conducting general upkeep to prevent deterioration. Examples of repair tasks include fixing broken windows or locks, repairing damaged guttering or roof tiles, repainting walls, replacing failing appliances, and mending faulty wiring or plumbing.

The key point to note is that repairs aim to restore assets to their original state rather than enhance them or add new functionality. As long as the repair work is carried out exclusively for rental business purposes, the expenditure typically qualifies as a fully tax-deductible expense. This means that you can offset the costs against your rental income for the year, thereby reducing your taxable profits. 

For example, if a tenant reports a broken boiler, the invoice from the plumber who fixes it can be categorised as an allowable revenue expense. Suppose you’re using the simplified cash basis for your tax return (available for property receipts of £150,000 or less). In that case, you’ll receive relief for the cost when calculating that year’s taxable rental profit.

When it comes to property, improvement work involves enhancing or expanding the property beyond its original condition. Instead of just fixing what’s there, improvements add extra features, amenities, or capacity. This could include adding an extension, converting a loft into a bedroom, upgrading the kitchen, adding bathrooms, or making a previously uninhabitable space livable. The key difference is that improvements result in a tangible increase in the property’s functionality or value. For tax purposes, expenditure on improvements is typically categorised as capital spending. This means that instead of an immediate income tax deduction, relief for capital costs is spread over time through capital allowances or base cost uplift. For example, if you spend £20,000 on a new bedroom with an ensuite, you wouldn’t get immediate income tax relief. However, when you eventually sell the property, £20,000 will be factored in as part of your allowable costs, reducing the taxable gain and hence the capital gains tax payable.

Understanding the distinction between repairs and improvements can be a bit tricky in practice. For example, what if you need to replace a damaged roof with more modern, longer-lasting tiles? Or if you decide to upgrade old single-glazed windows to new double-glazed units to meet the latest energy efficiency standards? In these cases, the boundaries between repairs and improvements can be clarified.

HMRC acknowledges this challenge and offers guidance for handling these situations. If an improvement element is incidental, or if the materials used are similar to the old ones, the full cost can be deducted as a repair. However, if the improvement is more substantial, only the true repair element is immediately deductible, and the improvement portion must be capitalised.

In cases of very significant improvement works, the entire project cost may need to be treated as capital expenditure, even if some elements are addressing damage. The specific nature and scale of the work undertaken determine the tax treatment. For example, if a few roof tiles blow off in a storm, the full invoice can be treated as a repair, even if the new tiles are slightly better quality. However, if you need to replace the entire living room carpet due to damage, the cost should be apportioned between the repair and enhancement elements.

Similarly, if you undertake a full refurbishment of a dated bathroom, including installing a new higher-spec suite, modern tiling, and underfloor heating, the entire refit cost would likely need to be capitalised due to the multiple improvement elements involved.

When determining whether a maintenance task falls under the category of repair or improvement, there are several important factors to consider:

1. Degree of Improvement: Assess whether the work represents a significant increase in performance or capacity, or if it simply involves using newer materials that incidentally change the functionality.

2. Extent of Work: Consider whether you are replacing a single component or undertaking a broader remodeling project. Larger jobs are more likely to be classified as improvements.

3. Old vs New: Evaluate how different the replacement items are from the original fixtures. Using materials that are broadly equivalent, even if they are of a somewhat higher quality, is more likely to be considered a repair.

If you are uncertain about how to categorise the work, it is advisable to seek guidance from a property tax specialist to determine where the boundary lies in your specific case. For landlords, correctly categorising upkeep work is crucial for claiming the right tax relief. This allows repair costs to be offset against income immediately, while improvement spending can be capitalised for long-term relief. This approach helps landlords budget for maintenance, manage cash flow, and maximise post-tax returns. When faced with a maintenance decision, consider whether the work is a repair to maintain the status quo or an improvement to enhance the property. The classification could have a significant impact on your financial bottom line.


Our blogs and articles are for information only. If you need help with your specific tax problem or need advice for your business please call us on 0800 135 7323