Skip to content 
COP9 Tax Investigation (Code of Practice 9)
Contractual Disclosure Facility Help
Facing a COP9 Tax Investigation under HMRC’s Code of Practice 9? Our specialist tax team prepares your CDF acceptance, negotiates firmly with FIS, and builds a full, honest disclosure to protect immunity. With clear timelines and calm guidance, we cut risk, reduce stress, and drive a fair settlement fast—so you can focus on your life and business.
Get Professional Help With COP9 Disclosure Report and Meetings with HMRC
When HMRC Uses Code of Practice 9
HMRC applies Code of Practice 9 when it suspects deliberate tax irregularities but proceeds civilly. Through COP9 you may get the Contractual Disclosure Facility, granting immunity if you admit deliberate behaviour and give full truthful disclosure. Cases include income tax, VAT PAYE, corporation tax and offshore issues You have 60 days to respond; expert advice helps produce complete outline and reach a fair settlement.
COP8 vs COP9: Which Procedure Applies to You?
Unsure whether your case is COP8 or COP9? Here’s the rule of thumb: COP8 addresses complex non-fraud errors or avoidance, while COP9 is used when HMRC suspects deliberate behaviour and offers the CDF route for civil settlement. If your disclosure is complete and honest under COP9, prosecution is usually set aside; under COP8, penalties still apply but focus on correcting position and tax due. Evidence, timelines and scope differ, so early specialist triage is vital to protect outcomes and reputation.
Do you need help with your Tax Return Filling?
Schedule a free 30‑minute consultation to discuss your personal tax compliance.
Whether you need help with simple tax returns or complex issues, we’ve designed our service to ensure you feel supported, informed, and in control every step of the way.
Get expert tax advice without visiting an office. Our virtual consultations can review, plan, and resolve your tax matters.
Book a consultation with a tax expert to identify any issues and receive the most effective strategy for future compliance.
Appointments can be scheduled online, by phone, or in person with a tax advisor. Contact our office to discuss your needs and next steps.
The values we live by
Honesty guides everything we do. We believe in transparent advice, accurate reporting, and doing what’s right for our clients every time.
We live and breathe tax. Our expert team delivers up-to-date, accurate advice so clients stay compliant, efficient, and ahead of the curve.
Every client matters. We take time to listen, understand your needs, and deliver personalised tax solutions with care and attention to detail.
OUR SERVICES
Our Practice Areas
We are a team of specialist tax advisors who are delivering expert guidance on tax compliance, international tax, HMRC investigations, business structuring, capital gains, inheritance tax, corporation tax and self assessment services.
We know personal taxes can be overwhelming. With us, your returns are accurate, on time, and tailored to your unique life.
We know running a business is hard enough. Let us handle your business taxes so you can focus on growth with confidence.
We know smart planning makes a difference. Our tax strategies help you stay compliant, save more, and plan for the future.
We know living abroad brings tax challenges. Whether in or out of the UK, we make your expat taxes smooth and stress-free
We know HMRC enquiries can be daunting. Count on us for expert support and peace of mind during your tax investigation.
We know unfair tax bills cause stress. If you disagree with HMRC, we’ll guide your tax appeal with precision and confidence.
We are leading network of qualified accountants, tax advisors and specialist business consultants in United Kingdom
Get an appointment with our Expert
To your situation
Your Questions - Our Answers
We are here to help you with any questions you may have
What is COP9, and why does HMRC offer the CDF?
COP9 (Code of Practice 9) is HMRC’s civil route when it suspects deliberate tax irregularities. Instead of opening a criminal case, HMRC may offer the Contractual Disclosure Facility, inviting you to make a full, truthful disclosure in exchange for a civil settlement. Think of it as a protected lane: if you move into it quickly and drive straight, you avoid the worst collisions. You will still be required to repay tax and interest, and a penalty may apply; however, the objective is to achieve closure without prosecution for the issues you disclose.
In practice, COP9 covers all major taxes—Self Assessment, VAT, PAYE, and Corporation Tax—and can include offshore assets, trusts, and third-party records. The roadmap is simple to describe yet demanding to deliver: confirm you want the facility, file an honest Outline Disclosure, gather evidence, and prepare a Formal Disclosure with calculations and signed certificates. Meetings with HMRC’s Fraud Investigation Service test your explanation, agree on timetables, and identify any gaps that need more work. Good project management matters because deadlines in the letter are strict, and missing them increases risk.
Where do specialists fit? At moments like this, process and proof beat charisma. At Tax Accountant, we triage the facts, map what HMRC is likely to request, and build a disclosure plan that keeps you ahead of the timeframe. We draft your Outline in plain language, assemble reconciliations, and manage every conversation with HMRC so nothing is said casually or late. If parts of the case are disputed—such as scope, behaviour tagging, or sampling—we propose structured solutions, sometimes using Alternative Dispute Resolution to resolve stalemates.
If a COP9 letter has landed, act now. Email the letter securely, book a confidential call, and receive a step-by-step plan today so you stay protected, credible, and in control. Early cooperation, clear records, and consistent messaging can significantly reduce penalties and expedite settlement for you.
What triggers COP9, and what evidence does HMRC rely on?
What puts someone on HMRC’s COP9 radar, and what evidence do they use? Usually it’s a pattern rather than a single slip: repeated under-declarations, false invoices, cash takings that don’t match card data, payroll irregularities, or offshore income that never appears on a return. Third-party information is powerful, too. Banks, payment processors, platforms, and even counterparties provide data that can contradict the figures reported. International reporting regimes mean overseas accounts and structures are less private than people assume, and HMRC can compare those feeds with your UK submissions.
Before a COP9 letter goes out, HMRC analysts test indicators of deliberate behaviour and assess whether the civil route is appropriate. They don’t need courtroom proof to suspect fraud; they need credible signals that a disclosure is warranted. Sometimes the trigger is a nudge letter you ignored, a tip from a former adviser, or mismatches discovered during another enquiry, such as VAT or employer compliance. Patterns across years, not single transactions, tend to be the red flags that matter most.
What should you do if you think you fit that profile, or a letter arrives? Start by preserving records, including bank statements, bookkeeping, invoices, contracts, and emails, so that nothing appears hidden or altered. Do not call the officer to “explain”; off-the-cuff comments create avoidable risk. Instead, appoint a specialist to lead communications and to map what HMRC likely already knows. A rapid scoping session should list the entities involved, accounts used, taxes affected, and distinguish between deliberate and non-deliberate behaviour. That scoping shapes a credible Outline Disclosure and a realistic timetable for the detailed report and meetings.
Our Tax Advisors run this playbook from day one. We set up a secure evidence vault, triage risks, prepare your Outline in plain English, and front all HMRC contacts. Handled correctly, you regain control, reduce penalties, and maintain a civil approach.
I’ve received a COP9 letter—what do I do in 48 hours, and what makes an Outline “valid”?
I’ve received a COP9 letter—what should my first forty-eight hours look like, and what goes in a valid Outline Disclosure? Your goal is calm control. First, read the letter and note the strict response deadline. Do not phone HMRC to explain; polite improvisation can undermine your position. Instead, appoint a specialist and give them the authority to speak on your behalf.
Next, preserve and organise records: bank statements, bookkeeping files, contracts, invoices, emails, payroll data, and any spreadsheets used to calculate returns. Create a simple timeline of key events and money flows, and list every entity and account affected by the issues—whether personal, corporate, or trust. This scoping prevents gaps and helps your adviser assess whether behaviour is deliberate or non-deliberate, which drives the correct procedure and penalty range.
A valid Outline Disclosure accomplishes three key objectives. One, it admits deliberate behaviour where it exists, in clear language. Two, it summarises all irregularities across taxes and years, including offshore angles, without yet claiming precision. Three, it sets expectations: what documents you can deliver quickly, where data must be reconstructed, and a timetable for the Formal Disclosure report with signed certificates. Piecing the story together slowly or selectively weakens credibility; a coherent overview now creates space for the details to emerge later.
What if the deadline is impossible because of illness or complex records? Ask early, with reasons, for extra time; sometimes extensions are allowed. But don’t drift: missing the deadline can lead HMRC to treat the offer as refused and to escalate.
Our Tax Accountants can draft your Outline within days, set up secure sharing, and script the communications plan, so every message lands on time and on point. We’ll also prepare you for the opening meeting, rehearse key answers, and create reconciliations that translate transactions into clear schedules HMRC trusts, reducing queries and speeding settlement considerably.
After accepting CDF, what happens—meetings, Formal Disclosure, penalties, and ADR?
What happens after you accept the CDF under COP9, and how do you keep momentum? Think of three phases: planning, meetings, and delivery. In planning, your adviser agrees on a timetable with HMRC, identifies data sources, and proposes payments on account to reduce interest and demonstrate cooperation. Expect targeted information requests; some arrive as Schedule 36 notices, which carry deadlines and scope limits that must be managed carefully.
Meetings with HMRC’s Fraud Investigation Service test your Outline, explore facts, and agree on next steps. Preparation is everything. We rehearse answers, align the narrative with supporting documents, and determine who speaks on each point. You should be candid, consistent, and calm; speculation causes avoidable detours. Where discussions stall on scope or method, Alternative Dispute Resolution can add structure and help both sides narrow the issues without losing your rights of appeal.
Delivery refers to the Formal Disclosure, which includes a detailed narrative with year-by-year computations, supporting evidence, and signed certificates, as well as a Statement of Assets and Liabilities. The report must cover all deliberate behaviour and any non-deliberate errors you’ve identified. Evidence beats assertion: bank trails, invoices, ledgers, contracts, and emails should support every figure. HMRC will review, raise questions, and negotiate penalties. Penalties typically depend on behaviour and the quality of your disclosure—telling, helping, and giving access to records. Stronger cooperation generally pushes percentages downward and accelerates agreement.
Our Tax Consultants run this process end-to-end. We build an evidence vault, prepare reconciliations that tie numbers to statements, and front all correspondence so tone stays professional and measured. If parts of the case belong in COP8 rather than COP9, we’ll explain why and document a corrected route. Our aim is simple: keep the matter civil, proportionate, and moving, so you return to normal operations with certainty and the lowest realistic penalty. Throughout, we track milestones visibly and prevent deadline slippage entirely.
Offshore accounts, COP8 vs COP9, ADR, and voluntary disclosure—how do they connect?
Do HMRC know about offshore accounts, and how do COP8, COP9, ADR, and voluntary disclosure fit together? Today, international reporting regimes require many foreign banks and financial institutions to send account data to tax authorities, which can then be matched against UK filings. That does not automatically prove wrongdoing, but it often highlights gaps that need explaining. If offshore issues exist, the safest path is a coordinated disclosure that aligns onshore and offshore stories, years, and behaviour.
Two main civil routes exist. COP9 is for suspected deliberate behaviour and comes with the Contractual Disclosure Facility, offering a civil settlement if you make a full, honest disclosure. COP8 is for complex, non-fraud disputes—often technical or avoidance-related—handled without the CDF contract. Getting the route right matters: the wrong frame can increase risk and slow resolution. If you are unsure, ask a specialist to quickly triage intent, evidence, and exposure.
For voluntary corrections where HMRC have not contacted you, the Worldwide Disclosure Facility provides a standardised way to regularise offshore income and assets. Used early, it can reduce penalties and demonstrate cooperation. Where an enquiry is already open or discussions stall on process rather than honesty, Alternative Dispute Resolution can help the parties agree on the scope, timelines, and methodology without resorting to a tribunal.
How we help: Our tax experts design one integrated plan. We review letters and records, determine whether COP8, COP9, or voluntary disclosure is appropriate, and then construct a coherent narrative supported by reconciliations and relevant documents. We manage information requests, challenge disproportionate demands, and front meetings so you remain calm and credible. If penalties arise, we will provide evidence, assistance, and access to records to help reduce percentages. Most importantly, we prevent piecemeal storytelling—a common mistake—by scoping all taxes, periods, and entities before numbers are finalised, protecting credibility and accelerating closure. Saves time, cost, and uncertainty.
How are penalties calculated under COP9, and what can I realistically do to reduce them?
HMRC penalties under COP9 depend on two things: behaviour and cooperation. Behaviour labels the inaccuracy as careless, deliberate, or deliberate and concealed. Cooperation measures the quality of disclosure, often summarised as telling, helping, and giving access to records. The sooner you report, the more you help HMRC quantify the true position, and the more complete your records are, the more penalties tend to fall within their statutory ranges. Offshore elements can alter ranges and increase complexity, so align COP9 with any Worldwide Disclosure Facility work to maintain consistency in your story.
What can you do in practice? Start with a credible Outline Disclosure that admits deliberate behaviour where it exists. Next, build a disciplined evidence pack: bank trails, sales ledgers, payroll files, contracts, and emails. Reconcile figures clearly so HMRC can follow the money. Offer a payment on account once numbers are roughly credible; it reduces interest and shows genuine intent to settle. If sampling is needed, propose a fair method and document it. Where disagreements are procedural rather than substantive, consider Alternative Dispute Resolution to facilitate progress without compromising appeal rights.
Avoid common mistakes. Do not drip-feed facts, argue every small point, or provide late, partial records. Do not underestimate non-tax heads such as VAT and PAYE, or forget connected entities. Silence, delay, or inconsistencies push penalties upwards and extend the enquiry.
At Tax Accountant, we help by diagnosing behavioural tags, drafting the Outline, designing reconciliations that HMRC trusts, and managing communications to ensure a professional tone. We evidence cooperation meticulously, negotiate firmly yet fairly, and aim for outcomes at the lower end of the range that still close the matter. Our penalty reviews are written in plain English, spreadsheet-backed, and focused on ensuring a successful outcome. Where facts are clear, settlements land faster and cost less.
How many years can HMRC look back under COP9, and how should I scope my disclosure timeline?
Where HMRC suspects deliberate behaviour, the assessment window can reach up to twenty years, depending on the tax. That horizon surprises people who expected four or six years. Planning for the long window is not about conceding everything; it is about credibility. A disclosure that cleanly scopes the earliest relevant year, identifies when behaviour began, and explains when it stopped will earn trust and keep arguments focused on evidence rather than speculation.
Start by mapping life events and business milestones against tax years: company launches, new bank accounts, major customers, shifts in bookkeeping software, changes of accountant, offshore moves, and asset purchases. Anchor uncertain memories using emails, statements, and archived backups. Then, list every tax head that might be affected, including Self Assessment, Corporation Tax, VAT, PAYE, and any offshore reporting requirements. Consistency across taxes matters; HMRC cross-checks totals and dates.
If records are thin in older years, explain what exists and how you plan to reconstruct the rest, for example, using bank statements, supplier confirmations, or representative sampling. Define clear-cut-off dates and justify them. When behaviour moved from careless to deliberate, say so and why. If a period genuinely falls under COP8 rather than COP9, document the reasoning.
Our Tax Advisors runs structured scoping sessions that translate narratives into a year-by-year plan. We build evidence maps, timeline charts, and working papers, then propose a timetable that HMRC can accept. The benefit is a faster, less combative enquiry with fewer fishing expeditions. When the picture is coherent, penalties usually fall and settlement accelerates. Show your letter, and we will outline the scope in days. Early clarity prevents detours, reduces penalties, and compresses timelines significantly for businesses, directors, and individuals facing multi-year investigative pressure.
What happens if I miss the sixty-day deadline or decide to reject the CDF invitation?
Missing the sixty-day window or sending an invalid response is a significant risk. HMRC can treat it as a rejection of the CDF and is no longer bound by the civil only undertaking for the issues that would have been disclosed. The case may escalate, and information powers will almost certainly follow. You may also miss the opportunity to frame the story proactively through a strong Outline Disclosure, which secures cooperation, credit, and momentum.
If you are overwhelmed by records or illness, ask for more time early on. Extensions are not automatic, but well-justified requests are sometimes agreed upon. Do not wait until the final week to organise data or decide strategy. If you truly have no deliberate behaviour to disclose, you can decline the CDF; however, your response should explain why COP9 is not suitable and confirm your willingness to cooperate through the appropriate civil route. Evidence matters more than adjectives.
If you accepted and later rescinded from the admission of deliberate behaviour, HMRC may consider the CDF repudiated and reassess next steps, including potential criminal action. Changing your story late can damage your credibility and lead to increased penalties.
How we help at Tax Accountant: we stabilise the situation quickly, draft timely responses, and build a delivery plan that HMRC can rely on. If COP9 is inappropriate, we will write a reasoned letter proposing COP8 or standard compliance checks and protect your position. If COP9 is right, we move fast to produce a valid Outline, agree on a timetable, and prevent slippage. We can also evaluate whether Alternative Dispute Resolution effectively addresses process disputes. When time is short, triage issues, prioritise records, and delegate. Structured project management restores momentum, reduces anxiety, and signals credible cooperation to HMRC from the outset.
How should I handle situations involving a spouse, ex-partner, or business partner during COP9?
Relationships matter in tax investigations. HMRC will examine who controlled decisions, who benefited, and how funds were transferred between connected individuals or entities. Disclosure should address roles clearly without speculation or blame. If a spouse, ex-partner, or former business partner is relevant to the tax loss, explain the facts neutrally and provide documentary evidence to support them. That protects you from inferences that silence might invite.
Start by mapping roles over time: who kept books, who invoiced, who approved payments, who managed banking, and who owned shares or partnership rights. Include any separation agreements, board minutes, loan notes, and dividend resolutions. When access to joint records is difficult, document the attempts you made and propose practical alternatives, such as bank statements from your side or supplier confirmations.
Be careful with privilege and confidentiality. Keep personal commentary out of the report and stick to verifiable facts. Where allegations exist, mark them as such and include supporting evidence if available. Do not withhold relevant documents just because they contain uncomfortable history; selective disclosure damages credibility.
Our Tax Accountants act as a buffer. We handle sensitive communications, organise evidence from third parties, and maintain a professional narrative. If the dispute turns on roles rather than behaviour, we may recommend Alternative Dispute Resolution to narrow issues and agree on practical next steps. If liabilities should be apportioned, we structure the numbers transparently and explain assumptions. The aim is fair treatment, a civil process, and a settlement that reflects reality without inflaming personal tensions. If shared liabilities arise, proportional calculations matter and should be transparent.
Clear schedules, narrative timelines, and signed statements help everyone understand their responsibilities and significantly shorten negotiations with HMRC, while preserving civility and accuracy.
What are the long-term implications after settlement, and who should be on my advisory team?
After a COP9 settlement, you will want predictability, clean systems, and lower risk. Expect closer scrutiny for a period, especially if your case involved complex structures or offshore elements. Use the momentum to strengthen controls: reconcile bank accounts monthly, document VAT treatments, tighten payroll onboarding, and implement evidence checklists for expenses and reliefs. Better processes reduce error, shorten future enquiries, and demonstrate learning if HMRC returns.
Who should support you? Your usual accountant remains essential for filings, but investigations are a niche area. A specialist leads strategy, manages tone with the Fraud Investigation Service, and knows how to structure evidence, meetings, and timetables. In complex cases, add a tax disputes lawyer for privilege and tribunal readiness. Together, the team keeps matters civil, proportionate, and moving.
What about future disclosures? If new issues surface, address them early through the appropriate route, such as the Worldwide Disclosure Facility for offshore matters, rather than waiting for contact. If disagreements become procedural, consider Alternative Dispute Resolution to reset discussions without losing appeal rights.
At Tax Accountant, we stay with clients post-settlement. We perform controls reviews, draft compliance calendars, and train staff so that the behaviours that caused problems do not repeat. We also create simple dashboards that track filings, reconciliations, and risk indicators. The payoff is peace of mind and stronger credibility with HMRC. If a letter arrives again, you are already prepared. Book a confidential review and we will map a practical, year-ahead plan in plain English with measurable milestones. We also map director responsibilities, delegated authorities, and approval thresholds. Small governance tweaks prevent big problems. Document decisions, retain evidence, and revisit risks quarterly to keep confidence high and compliance effortless always.
How does a Schedule 36 information notice work, and how should I respond?
A Schedule 36 notice is HMRC’s legal request for information or documents “reasonably required” to check your tax position. In a COP9 context, notices may ask for bank statements, sales ledgers, contracts, emails, device backups, or explanations of sampling and methodology. The key is to have a proportionate scope and provide timely, complete responses. Late, partial, or argumentative replies drive penalties up and confidence down.
Start by reading the notice line by line and diarying each deadline. Build a response index that mirrors HMRC’s numbering, so nothing is missed. Where requests are unclear or overly broad, your adviser should negotiate scope, propose staged delivery, or agree on pragmatic substitutes (for example, supplier confirmations if ancient invoices are missing). Never destroy or alter records; if something truly doesn’t exist, say so plainly and explain why.
In parallel, assemble reconciliations that tie totals back to statements and ledgers. Good working papers prevent follow-up fishing trips. If personal data of third parties appears, discuss redaction protocols. For electronic data, export searchable formats (such as CSV or PDF with text) rather than screenshots. Consider implementing a secure portal for large files to ensure transfers are auditable and encrypted.
If you disagree with the notice, there are limited appeal routes, and tribunal oversight exists for inspections. In practice, cooperation with firm boundary-setting works best. At Tax Accountant, we map each request to exact evidence, draft covering narratives, and schedule deliveries that HMRC can trust. We’ll push back where the scope strays beyond “reasonably required,” but we’ll still provide what matters to progress your case.
Handled well, a Schedule 36 process demonstrates telling, helping, and access to records—the behaviours that lower penalties. Handled poorly, it lengthens the enquiry, invites assumptions of concealment, and can trigger enforcement. Choose clarity, structure, and completeness from day one.
What goes into the Formal Disclosure report, and how do I make it credible?
The Formal Disclosure is the backbone of your COP9 settlement. It converts your high-level Outline into evidenced numbers, signed statements, and a narrative. A strong report covers scope, method, calculations, evidence, and governance. First, define scope: taxes, entities, years, and behaviours (careless versus deliberate). Explain when and why the behaviour started, changed, or stopped. Consistency across Self Assessment, Corporation Tax, VAT, and PAYE matters.
Second, set out the methodology. If records were reconstructed, describe sources, sampling, assumptions, and limitations. If you used estimates, show how you validated them and include sensitivity checks to demonstrate the validity of your results. Third, provide calculations: year-by-year schedules for tax, interest, and proposed penalties. Tie totals back to bank statements and ledgers using clear reconciliation bridges. Include a Statement of Assets and Liabilities, loan accounts, director drawings, and offshore interests where relevant.
Fourth, evidence. Append bank statements, invoices, contracts, payroll files, and key emails. Use an exhibits index and cross-references so HMRC can follow the trail. Provide machine-readable files; don’t bury figures in images. Fifth, governance. Include signed certificates, a disclosure statement, and a controls plan showing how errors will be prevented. Show who did what and when, and record review steps.
Tone matters. Avoid excuses; stick to facts. Admit deliberate behaviour where it exists, and tag non-deliberate errors accurately. Propose a timetable for any residual items and consider a payment on account to reduce interest. If disagreements are procedural—scope, timelines, or sampling—propose Alternative Dispute Resolution to preserve momentum.
Our Tax Experts build Formal Disclosures that HMRC trusts, including precise schedules, explanations, and complete evidence bundles. We front correspondence, prepare you for meetings, and negotiate penalties with documentation that earns cooperation credit. The result is a faster review, fewer queries, and a settlement that closes the issue, allowing you to focus on running your business.
How do I decide between COP8 and COP9, and what happens if HMRC chooses the wrong route?
COP8 and COP9 solve different problems. COP9 includes the Contractual Disclosure Facility. COP8 handles complex, non-fraud disputes such as technical errors, avoidance, or valuation disagreements. Picking the right lane matters because evidence differs. Under COP9, you admit deliberate behaviour for a civil settlement; under COP8, you contest issues.
Start with intent and evidence. Were sales suppressed, invoices fabricated, records destroyed, assets hidden offshore, or returns knowingly misstated? That points to COP9. Are the issues about interpretation, sampling, transfer pricing, residence, or relief conditions? That points to COP8. Build a matrix of issues, years, taxes, behaviours, then tag each. Mixed cases happen; a plan can accept COP9 for specific behaviours while arguing technical points.
What if HMRC sent COP9, but you believe the matter is non-deliberate? Do not ignore the letter. Respond within sixty days, explain why COP9 is unsuitable, and propose the appropriate civil route with evidence. Conversely, if HMRC is using COP8 but clear, deliberate behaviour exists, consider a voluntary approach to regularise issues and earn credit.
COP9 expects an Outline and a Formal Disclosure with signed certificates. COP8 relies on information exchange, position papers, and, in some cases, Alternative Dispute Resolution. Penalty outcomes differ based on behaviour tagging and cooperation quality. In either route, telling, helping, and giving access to records lowers risk.
We specialise in route assessment. We review letters, sample records, and conduct interviews with key people, and then produce a recommendation along with a delivery timetable. If a route change is necessary, we draft the correspondence and manage the tone to ensure the case remains civil. Choosing correctly saves time, reduces penalties, and prevents escalation risk. The aim is a fair, prompt resolution grounded in facts and supported by evidence.
Can I make a voluntary disclosure to avoid COP9, and when should I use the Worldwide Disclosure Facility?
Yes—if HMRC has not contacted you, a voluntary disclosure can regularise underpaid tax and reduce penalties. For offshore matters, the Worldwide Disclosure Facility (WDF) is the standard route; onshore issues can be disclosed through other HMRC channels. Acting early helps: unprompted, well-evidenced disclosures usually attract lower penalties than cases triggered by HMRC intelligence.
Start with scoping. List all taxes, entities, accounts, and years. Identify deliberate versus non-deliberate behaviour honestly; do not rebrand deliberate actions as careless. Gather bank statements, ledgers, and contracts, then reconstruct gaps using supplier confirmations or reasonable sampling. Build year-by-year computations for tax and interest, and prepare a clear narrative explaining what happened, why, and what controls will change to prevent recurrence.
When is WDF appropriate? Use it for offshore income, gains, or assets, including foreign accounts, investments, trusts, and entities. Align the WDF with any onshore corrections to ensure the story remains consistent. If HMRC has already written to you under COP9, speak to a specialist before acting; a mis-stepped disclosure could undermine CDF protections or appear piecemeal.
What about immunity? Voluntary disclosure does not automatically grant immunity from prosecution, but it usually lowers the risk in civil cases when made in a timely and complete manner. If indicators of fraud are strong and HMRC is already engaged, COP9 with the CDF may provide a clearer civil framework than ad hoc disclosures.
Our Tax Advisors run voluntary disclosure projects from start to finish. We triage intent, select the right route, and draft submissions in plain English with reconciliations HMRC can test. We also manage payments on account to reduce interest and demonstrate cooperation. If negotiations stall on scope or timetable, we may propose Alternative Dispute Resolution to reset progress. Our goal is simple: correct tax paid, penalties minimised, and a credible narrative that closes the matter so you can move forward with confidence.
How do I prepare for the COP9 opening meeting so I stay calm, accurate, and credible?
Treat the opening meeting as a structured interview, not a debate. The goal is to confirm the Outline Disclosure, agree on the next steps, and set a timetable for the Formal Disclosure. Preparation prevents surprises. First, align your timeline with documents. Build a chronology of events, money flows, and decision points. Cross-check dates against emails, bank statements, payroll runs, and invoices. If you are unsure about a detail, say you will verify rather than guessing.
Second, decide roles. Your adviser should lead, you answer factual questions, and nobody speculates. Prepare short explanations for each issue: what happened, when, who was involved, and how you propose to quantify it. Bring an index of records that you can supply quickly and a plan for items that require reconstruction. If third-party delays occur, provide evidence to support them.
Third, manage tone and logistics. Arrive with printed timelines and a pack of sample documents. Keep answers concise; let your adviser handle technical points and disputes about scope. If a question exceeds the Outline, acknowledge it and propose addressing it in the Formal Disclosure with supporting documents. Take notes, record actions, and confirm deadlines before you leave.
Fourth, consider early mitigation. Offer a payment on account once figures are credible, and agree on sampling or data-gathering methods that both sides accept. If scope or timetable disagreements risk stalling progress, suggest Alternative Dispute Resolution to maintain momentum without compromising the right to appeal.
At Tax Accountant, we rehearse the meeting, run the Q&A, refine the talking points, and build the handouts HMRC requires. We front the discussion, capture follow-ups, and confirm minutes in writing. The outcome is a focused session that protects credibility, locks in deadlines, and accelerates settlement by turning intentions into a documented plan everyone can follow.
What digital record-keeping and controls should I implement after a COP9 settlement?
Post-settlement, strong digital hygiene prevents repeat issues and shows learning. Start by mapping your data sources: accounting software, banking feeds, POS systems, payroll, expense apps, and cloud storage. Enable bank feeds and lock monthly reconciliations to ensure balances match statements. Use unique user logins with role-based permissions, two-factor authentication, and an audit trail that records who changed what and when.
Next, standardise document capture. Implement invoice-capture tools that extract supplier, date, VAT, and line totals into your ledgers. Review exceptions weekly. Store contracts, board minutes, loan agreements and dividend paperwork in a structured, searchable repository. Tag documents by year, entity, counterparty, and tax head—Self Assessment, Corporation Tax, VAT, PAYE—so future enquiries are easy to service.
Build controls around high-risk areas. For VAT: evidence tax points, partial exemption calculations, and cross-border rules. For payroll: maintain starter forms, status checks, benefits and expenses records, and RTI reconciliation to payments. For director transactions, maintain loan account schedules and approval notes for dividend payments. For cash sales, reconcile daily takings with bank deposits and inventory movements.
Governance matters. Create a monthly close checklist with sign-offs from both the preparer and the reviewer. Document judgments such as revenue recognition or relief claims, and keep supporting calculations. Schedule quarterly reviews with your accountant and an annual “evidence drill” where you rebuild a sample return from source documents to test robustness.
Technology helps, but discipline wins. Avoid screenshot bookkeeping; export machine-readable files HMRC can test. Backup data across regions and retain records for statutory periods. At Tax Accountant, we design control frameworks, train staff, and monitor early-warning signals, such as unusual margins, late postings, or unresolved bank discrepancies. The payoff is fewer errors, simpler audits, and faster resolution if HMRC asks questions again, because your evidence is organised and easy to share.